The Top 100 Magic: The Gathering Cards of All Time (#50-41)

To celebrate the 25th anniversary of Magic, we brought together the hivemind of ChannelFireball Pros, content contributors, and more to create the ultimate list: The 100 greatest Magic cards of all time.
In this episode, Mashi is joined by Reid Duke, Brian Kibler, and the inventor of “The Deck” himself, Brian Weissman, in Las Vegas, NV to break down and debate the next 10 slots on the list.
Tune in next week for #40-31, with new guests! is your premier source for Magic: The Gathering strategy, singles, sealed product and accessories!


Messi #Goat Milan says:

I love me some Oath of Druids and you can get the Eldrazi Titans in Oath decks. But there are alot of different builds of it the Inferno Titan Oath of Druids variant is very popular. Because Titan is very hard for Workshops, Humans, Delver and Eldrazi Vintage decks. Oath is love i think it should probably be higher but so should Wheel of Fortune and Timetwister

Daniel Brause says:

I know this list was made before DRS ban in legacy, so I’d be curious how the rankings would shake out if they did them again now. I can’t help but feel DRS should have been at least higher than delver, considering that DRS is banned in both legacy and modern while delver isn’t.

chrisli 33 says:

Assasins’s trophy should definitely be on the list

Vítor Salles says:

Best episode so far. People talking about events and experiences, really nice!

Skylar Beverage says:

If Reid tells me Gaea’s Cradle is the best, then it’s the best.

Jacob Davis says:

Tbh with the existence of yawgmoths will I think it is safe to say wheel of fortune is better than timetwister as a functional card effect. BUT timetwister is blue so it makes up for a slightly weaker effect.

hippojump says:

17:38 There are currently 3 creatures banned in each of standard, modern and legacy. Of these, only Deathrite Shaman is a repeat. In vintage, 2 creatures are restricted.

Feakos says:

Always nice to see Brian Weissman

Woolier Than Thou says:

“There was a time in Magic, when there was one best deck.” So Ben Weissman came up with Temur Energy? Sweet.

SmaugUKA says:

On this week’s episode of, “Is This Card Better Than Wheel of Fortune?” we’ve created a spinoff titled, “Is This Card Better Than Timetwister?”.

Tune in each week and find out.

Unnamed Gio says:

Did they forget delver?

Vidar Thorsby says:

Reid Duke and Brian Kibler. Yes! It is almost like my fan fiction.

michaelgerard2 says:

When is storm crow going to show up on this list?

Trevor Holness says:

Creatures that have been banned at one point or another
Serendib Effret (Extended)
Lin Sivvi (Masques Block)
Goblin Lackey (Extended)
Goblin Recruiter (Extended + Legacy)
Hermit Druid (Extended + Legacy)
Metalworker (Extended + Legacy)
Worldgorger Dragon (Legacy)
Arcbound Ravager (Standard + Mirrodin Block)
Disciple of the Vault (Standard + Extended + Mirrodin Block)
Stoneforge Mystic (Standard + Modern + Extended)
Wild Nacatl (Modern)
Bloodbraid Elf (Modern)
Deathrite Shaman (Modern + Legacy)
Emrakul, the Promised End (Standard)
Reflector Mage (Standard)
Rogue Refiner (Standard)
Rampaging Ferocedon (Standard)
Felidar Guardian (Standard)

Yeah, that’s a long list. I think I need to get out more

turn2stormcrow says:

The real question is “is this better than Assassin’s Trophy?

staticsight says:

If Ancestral isn’t #1 on this list I’mma be salty

Kaiju Team says:

Reid duke is good looking

Anita Bee says:

Reid’s magnificent hair swinging from side to side is very distracting. Can you make him wear a helmet next time? I could only make out the word “card” in this whole video.

Simon S. says:

My Guess for the top 3 on this list would be 3:Shahrazad/Ancestral Recall 2:Contract from Below 1:Lotus (If Ante cards are on the list at least)

Toni Anders says:

Will they find it this time – a card truly better than Wheel of Fortune?

Emmett Ochrach-Konradi says:

What cards did they say this episode? I was pretty locked in on reid’s hair.

Thedeadjoker666 says:

Best lineup yet :O

 Write a comment


Do you like our videos?
Do you want to see more like that?

Please click below to support us on Facebook!